The Non-Protective Types
It was 3 o’clock in the morning on a Friday night. Kenya, her boyfriend Ez, my boyfriend and I had just left Hurricane on 2nd Avenue in downtown Nashville. We danced so hard I sweated out my perm. There’s nothing like the DJ’s down south who know how to make a party pop. (I miss that being in NYC where in 2011 they play Joe Budden in the club. Really NY DJ’s?) I was hungry. We hugged Kenya and Ez goodbye nearly skipping to the pizza shop on the corner. One slice of pepperoni pizza was just what I needed.
On the walk to the car the beau and I chatted about how cool Kenya and her Ez were to hang out with. We were totally giddy over their cuteness as a couple. As I was devouring my pizza, my knee length form fitting black dress was slowly rising due to my new weight gain that seemed to hit my thighs and derrière the most. There were three fat guys on the corner looking seemingly bummy. Halfway between reaching the car and being nearly 20 steps past the random guys, my dress was still misbehaving. I couldn’t pull down my dress fast enough before one of the guys yelled: “Nice ass.” I mumbled something to the effect of go to hell, not really loud enough for any of them to hear. Chris remained silent.
“Nice ass, and your boyfriend ain’t gon’ do nothing about it,” another screamed.
I, dumbfounded, waited for my boyfriend’s response. Silence.
“Just like I said, he ain’t gon’ do nothing about it. Bitch ass nigga,” he yelled.
I’m now livid, and can’t help to think this would have never happened with any of my exes. Not only would it not have happened with any of my exes, but years prior in my reckless years it wouldn’t have flown with me either.
In an attempt not to emasculate Chris I looked over at him expecting him to at least acknowledge what was happening. He said nothing. [1]
My anger hadn’t subdued by the time we reached his apartment. I lashed into him with a number of questions.
“Why didn’t you say anything?”
“Were you scared?”
“You’re supposed to be a protector!” I screamed.
Admittedly he was scared. He froze up and didn’t know what to do. After 45 minutes of my temper tantrum I realized this was nothing new to him. He had been called gay, tested by other men and considered weak his entire life for being short, skinny and light skinned. My anger quickly turned to sadness. I cried for him. The man I loved walked around with fear in his heart. Something I just was not used to.
Months later he would reveal that said incident was the beginning of the end of our relationship.
“You never looked at me the same after that night,” he said. “You didn’t respect me as a man.”
He was right.
It is said that women need to feel like their man is the protector and provider for any relationship to work. Eh…provider not necessarily, especially with the influx of independent women. Although, for me, there does need to be an indication he could be the provider if he had to. But protector is a must.
After that night my own issues of how I viewed manhood and masculinity would find its way into our tough conversations. Prior to Chris I had only been in love with men who were 6’1 and taller, dark skinned, and at least 205 lbs.[2] Yet there I was dating a man who was the antithesis of the exes, which was great, until the night I knew he couldn’t protect me.
I don’t know if that incident ultimately ended our relationship. I’m actually sure it did not as there were a myriad of other issues that basically boiled down to timing and compatibility. But after him I was left asking myself, how important is it to feel like your man can protect you?
I decided it’s a must. And it’s not something I’m willing to budge on. Not even a little.
[1] In retrospect expecting him to do something could have gotten both of us seriously hurt or killed. But I didn’t expect him to walk up to them, start an argument or kick their asses. I did want him to at least acknowledge that they had disrespected me. Later there would be other incidents that I didn’t feel he could defend himself or me if something happened.
[2] The incident that happened would have most likely never happened with my any of my exes or best male friends because they don’t carry themselves in a way where they look like they could or should be tested. More than anything, it bothered me that Chris looked like he wouldn’t do anything so they tried him. And he proved them right.
Hate the Ladies
Monday my timeline went apeshit over a picture Bossip (its name derived from Black gossip) posted to accompany its exclusive interview with Esther Baxter. Baxter, the ex-girlfriend of D-list rapper Joe Budden, has somewhat remained under the radar until recently. Now she will be forever linked to her relationship drama with a rapper who hasn’t had a hit song since “Pump, pump, pump it up.”
Budden’s “Ordinary Love Shit Part. 3,” is a tell all song where he gets some unresolved tension off his chest. In the song he discloses private details about the tragedies of his dysfunctional relationship with Esther. He rhymes:
Yeah we beefin’ I dragged you off the bed
I swear to this day I re-enacted in my head
So I held you up, wasn’t what I aimed to do
I aint attack you, Bitch I was restrainin’ you!
I lost my unborn daughter when we fought
I’m thinkin I killed Aspen!
And that’s when I thought that we’d be dead awhile
But we decided to reconcile
And all I could do is laugh at myself
As I thought, why is ol’girl suckin up Derrick Ward for?
The song continues on in a tirade depicting Esther as a trifling, cheating, “whore.” In addition to disclosing all of their business, whether true or not, he admits to fighting Esther and the loss of more than one child. (She has only admitted to losing one child). When Esther got wind of the song getting attention on the net, she was not pleased with his assessment of her or their relationship.
Within the same week Esther and Joe took to Twitter to tell their very different sides of what occurred. Esther revealed the real reason they lost their child- domestic violence- and threatened to release the court documents as proof. Joe refuted the claims saying, “Women have to think of new lines besides he hit me.” Tweets were eventually erased, but the damage had already been done. And the two had served as a spectacle for the entire web to see.
The erased tweets didn’t protect Esther from the misguided Budden fans (how does he still have fans?). Fans, women and men, attacked Esther for sleeping with a football player while she was still in a committed with Joe. Although these were nothing more than allegations, because he put it in a song it must be true. Random people who don’t know him or her from a hole in the wall, chimed in that Esther was a whore who deserved her lot.
Yesterday picked up where the previous week left off. In hopes of telling her side of the story, Bossip claims Esther reached out to them. Her nine-minute on camera interview dispelled rumors of being currently pregnant or cheating on Joe while they were together. She was also firm in her response about not going back to Joe after he beat her on that awful night in February. For the remainder of the interview she painfully recounts that night describing how she was choked, hit and how he sat on her pregnant stomach eventually causing them to lose their unborn daughter.
Bossip couldn’t leave it at the interview, the pictures of her bruises, the New Jersey charges against Joe, and the restraining order. Bossip had to take it to the most repulsive level by posting the picture of her dead fetus.
People used Twitter to express their disgust for them taking it too far, including Russell Simmons’ Global Grind blog, which suggested their followers boycott the website. Bossip’s response was, “She released the photo to us.” Esther later denied releasing the photo of her dead fetus and it was eventually taken down.
But the photo was nothing but a mere distraction from the real issues at play: women being seen as disposable and the therapy BOTH Esther and Joe need immediately.
Opinions ran the gamut of Esther being trifling to Bossip being a disgrace to the blogosphere. Again, very little attention was paid to the fact that Joe Budden beat this woman to the point of her losing their child.
If Esther released the photo of her dead fetus Bossip should have used discretion by not publishing it. But I don’t expect much from Bossip. I imagine if she did release the photo, she wanted people to see what Joe took from her. It is one thing to say, “He killed our child,” and quite another to show it. Bottom line: the photo should have never been published.
The more important issue is society’s devaluing of women. In the case of Esther Baxter, onlookers strongly justified her being beaten because of her video vixen, groupie, gold digging, whorish ways (their words not mine). And this is where we as a society are totally screwed up.
I don’t care what label sexist women and men want to hang over her head, no woman deserves to be hit by a man for any reason. Ever.
The leading cause of death for pregnant women is homicide. Eight-five, yes, 85 percent of domestic violence victims are women. So the argument that men get abused too is moot here.
The other issue is the therapy both Joe and Esther need in order to heal. Joe has admittedly rapped about being on meds for his chemical imbalance; and accusations of him being a woman-beater were thunderous long before Esther. Joe is hurting. He is emoting through violence against women. Esther’s trauma is unfathomable. She cannot continue on as if this will not affect her in the future. Her heart needs to heal. And so does her soul.
We must shift gears on the direction of our conversations around domestic violence. Insinuating the woman must have done something to get hit or blaming her for the abuse is counterproductive. And the notion that it’s excusable for certain types of women to be abused is flawed and morally corrupt.
Joe Budden should be behind bars. His behavior and remorseless attitude makes me sick to my stomach. Co-signing his behavior makes you a part of the problem. It becomes evident we have to begin with the children teaching love, self-worth and how to express themselves without violence. Changing the tone of discourse around violence against women helps change mindsets, slowly, but surely. Only then may we be considered fully human and incapable of being disposed of.
Society must do better by its women. It must.
‘Cause if we don’t we’ll have a race of babies who will hate the ladies. – Tupac
“Jumping the Broom” Review
When the trailer of Jumping the Broom began circulating on the net I was ecstatic. Finally! A black movie without Madea toting her piece of steel or Precious-esque caricatures was long overdue. Directed by Salim Akil (Girlfriends and The Game) and produced by Bishop T.D. Jakes, the romantic comedy delved into the surface class divisions among Blacks while celebrating Black love.
After an unsuccessful bout with men, Sabrina (Paula Patton) vows to God to “save her cookies” until marriage for her husband. Moments later Sabrina nearly hits Jason (Laz Alonso) with her car. After six months of courtship, Jason learns Sabrina is heading to China for her job. Jason makes the ultimate decision to leave Wall Street, propose to the love of his life and accompany her to China as husband and wife.
The Taylors and Watsons are from different sides of the track. They meet for the first time at the Watson’s Martha Vineyard estate where the wedding will take place. Pam (Loretta Devine), a postal worker, is annoyed with her son’s future wife for never crossing the bridge to Brooklyn to properly introduce herself. Her best friend and co-worker, Shonda (Tasha Smith), instructs her to give Sabrina a chance and remember the lessons she learned in anger management.
Pam is not impressed as she, her brother-in-law Uncle Willie (Mike Epps), her nephew Malcolm (DeRaye Davis) and Shonda arrive at the Martha’s Vineyard mansion. Before the luggage hits the curb, Pam can’t help but to throw shade at Sabrina and her mother Claudine (Angela Bassett). Claudine flaunts her family’s wealth and education by speaking French sporadically. She is a tad uppity, but more so proud of the lineage of her family who never were slaves, and in fact owned slaves. (Did they really just go there? Mis-education of the negro is alive and well.)
When Sabrina reveals she doesn’t want to jump the broom all hell breaks loose. Jumping the broom is a tradition in Jason’s family, dating back to slavery when slaves weren’t allowed to marry; and the only thing they could do to symbolize their union was jump the broom. Pam is livid at the suggestion of not jumping the broom and calls the family out on thinking they are “better than” because they have money.
Jason and Sabrina succumb to doubts on whether they should marry when their families continue to fight. Lust is in the air between the maid of honor, Blythe (Meagan Good) and the chef, while Shonda fights her urge to cougar it up with 20-year-old Sebastian (Romeo Miller). Sabrina’s funny and crass aunt Geneva (Valarie Pettiford) causes quite the stir with drama and her impromptu “Sexual Healing” tribute to the couple since they haven’t had sex in six months. And a curveball is thrown in the plot when gasping family secrets are revealed.
Jumping the Broom was refreshing in the sense that it depicted multi-dimensional characters. Black love was celebrated; and for the most part the despicable Black woman tropes- emasculating, downtrodden, bitchy, hopeless- were non-existent. Creating a space for educated and successful Blacks, who’s origin is not predated to poverty is a story that needs to be told more often.
My problem with the film was the extremities of the class distinctions. Pam as the working-poor widowed mother who was attitudinal, uncultured, mouthy and domineering didn’t work for me. The Taylors arrived on Martha’s Vineyard as the poor Black people that have never been anywhere or seen anything. Uncle Willie joked about not having ever been on a boat because he thought it would take him back to Africa. In another scene Kunta Kinte was the butt of jokes. Pam didn’t know shrimp cocktail was served cold, and criticized her son for their reception menu consisting of sushi and oysters. At the other end of the spectrum was the elite Watsons. Although the father, Mr. Watson (Brian Stokes Mitchell) was modest, Claudine boasts about spending a half a million on her daughter’s education. Her occasional blurts of French in front of a room full of people who don’t speak French, and her believing the Taylor’s to be “simple” and “tacky” was over the top.
Class distinctions don’t have to be so extreme to the point it’s unrealistic. Someone from the hood can have traveled abroad and appreciate the delicacies of Japanese cuisine. And people with degrees and wealth can be down-to-earth. Not all wealthy Blacks are uppity, just as not all poor Blacks are uncultured. Anyone who knows people from both ends of the spectrum understand this.
Although this film tried hard to steer away from Tyler Perry similarities, it failed. The cringe worthy comments made by Epps, Devine and DeRaye Davis were borderline coonery. The preachy religious messages we were bombarded with were overdone ( Arielle Loren’s piece on this is worth the read). Stereotypes weren’t exactly null and void either. Besides a man in drag, a substantially better written and directed script, Jumping the Broom looked slightly similar to the tired formulaic methods perfected by Mr. Perry.
The star-studded cast carried the film. Loretta Devine and Angela Bassett are veterans who have nailed those types of characters time and time again. Meagan Good played the same gold-digging typecast role she has played in every movie and TV show. Laz Alonso did exceptionally well as his first leading role, whereas Paula Patton’s performance fell flat. She was nothing more than a reincarnation of her Just Wright character.
At best, the movie was cute. It was not a great movie.
Blacks are so desperate for positive representation on the big screen that anything that is the antithesis of Perry will get raving reviews. I get it. We want to see a balance of something other than the tragic poor ignorant Black people who can’t catch a break in life. However, arguable and subjective positivity alone has never won Oscars. And the last time I checked, cute never equated to great. Unfortunately, cute may be all we can hope for when the only other option is a man in a dress.
From the Classroom: Reflections on Education
“Your child’s future was the first to go with budget cuts. If you think that hurts then, wait here comes the uppercut. The school was garbage in the first place, that’s on the up and up. – Lupe “Words I Never Said”
I cried uncontrollably in the empty theater during “Waiting for Superman.” It wasn’t a pretty cry. There weren’t two tiny tears streaming down my face as I cried silently. It was a heaving, sniffling, shoulders moving up and down and type of cry, so heavy that my significant other looked over and immediately wrapped his arms around my shoulders and began rubbing my back.
“Waiting for Superman” is a controversial documentary that explores our nation’s failing public school systems. The audience is introduced to five parents desperately trying to save their children from the horrors of a public school education. Full of hope and prayers, parents enter their kids into a lottery for the most coveted charter schools in their cities. Watching involved parents anxiously wait the fate of their child’s future, only to be turned away after all was said and done, was heartbreaking.
I attended both public and private schools. Kindergarten through 5th grade I spent my days at South East Academic Center (SEAC). SEAC was a magnet school. My mother went through a strenuous process before I was accepted as a kindergartner. She was interviewed, it was mandatory she be involved with a specific number of school activities and she was bound to her commitments by signing a contract. I, as five-year-old, was required to take a number of tests before the final decision was made. SEAC was an inner city public magnet school with predominantly black students from all parts of town. As one of the best K-8 schools in the city, it logically made sense to have the best teachers in the district. For 6th and 7th grade I attended two different private Lutheran schools where I was one of no more than four black students in the entire school. In 8th grade when I moved to Nashville I went to the middle school I was zoned for, which was a public school. And high school I went to Nashville School of the Arts where I auditioned for drama and dance and was accepted for both.
Unfortunately, not every child has a parent(s) who valued education the same way my mother did. This became painstakingly obvious when I began substitute teaching in the Uniondale Public School District. Like many writers who move to the big city to pursue a dream, things don’t take off as quickly as you expect. Although I was freelancing I needed a supplemental income.
Uniondale is a predominantly Latino and black suburb in Long Island, therefore the classrooms reflect that ethnic make up.
On my very first day the district sent me to a 7th grade middle school classroom. I was nervous, but shook my fear thinking, ‘How bad could it be? They are only 12.’ My naiveté quickly vanished when I was greeted with piercing stares from a rowdy group of kids wanting to know, “Who are you and where is Mrs. Andrews?” Thirty seconds into me laying down the law with the kids about what was not allowed, I was being mocked because of my southern accent.
“You must be from the country somewhere,” said students simultaneously as the class erupted with laughter.
“Be quiet, please,” I’d reply. “If you have something to say raise your hand and wait to be called on.”
“Be quiet, please. If you have something to say raise your hand and I will call on you,” a few students mocked.
From that point on the day got progressively worse. Instead of being able to concentrate solely on “teaching,” going over the assignments and answers their teacher had left for them, I spent my day rattling off a list of commands.
“Be quiet.”
“Sit down.”
“Stop running.”
“Don’t speak when I am speaking.”
“Hey, don’t get fresh.”
“What’s your name? If you don’t do your work I will be putting your name on my list for your teacher of students who did not behave.”
“Do your work.”
“Don’t throw that!”
It wasn’t much better for the TA. They treated him with little respect as well. As I stood around regaining order every 10 minutes, I realized some of the students in middle school already had no desire to learn. One boy who was about twice my size and weight, refused to do any work or even sit at a desk. When a TA attempted to coerce him into doing it he still refused replying, “This s*** is boring.” By that age a number of students freely use the f-bomb, harass their classmates, have a defeatist attitude and are uninterested in learning the way the material is being taught; I refuse to believe they are uninterested in learning altogether.
I vowed to never do middle school again. Like ever.
Elementary school was my niche. In the 1st grade children are eager to learn. At this age they are naturally inquisitive about everything. They revel in getting the answer correct. And as the “teacher” I got a fuzzy feeling inside seeing them actually learn. Doing basic addition with them, seeing them shout out the answers excitedly, was what made the distinction between my love for elementary and loathe for middle school.
Being in the classroom, walking the halls, talking to teachers, administrators, and other substitutes, solidified what I’ve always felt- education is such a critical foundation for one’s life. It also reinforced why we need to remain in constant discourse about the crappy American education system and how to improve it. Here are my reflections:
1. Money, money, money. “Everything is about money, but nobody [at the top] cares because their kids don’t have to go to these schools.” –Anonymous teacher. The Uniondale School District, which consists of five schools, had a total budget of $155,993,010 for the 2010-2011 school year. I won’t break down all of the allocations, but here are a few that I’ve rounded off: $62.9 million went to Teaching-Regular School, $12.5 million to Programs-Students w/Disabilities, $1.3 million for Occupational Education, $4.8 million for Library, Media, & Instruct. Tech, etc. I’m not a numbers person so that seems like a fair allocation of funds. Yet I personally know teachers who have paid for certain books or supplies that the school did not cover. With nearly a $156 million budget, why should a teacher have to reach in her purse for anything? Something isn’t adding up.
2. Every child learns differently. Our black and Latino children have cultural differences in comparison to WASPs, which is who our education system has always been structured toward and after. Archaic teaching methods may not be effective in the 21st century. Further, black and brown children must be challenged through methods that may be unconventional.
3. Teachers are underpaid. Teachers are underpaid. Teachers are underpaid.
4. Our crapola school system is not all the teacher’s fault.
5. Parents must be involved in every aspect of their child’s education. You can’t expect the school to do it all. Black people, we have to teach our kids our history. Schools certainly aren’t doing it. And as important as Dr. King and Rosa Parks are, there is so much more to our history than the Civil Rights Movement.
6. Middle school is a critical point in children’s lives. You have to catch them here before they get to high school. Some have already given up at this point.
7. Black men are needed in public schools. We’re losing our black boys. They are slipping through the cracks with very few people giving a damn. They need to see your face, black men! A face that looks like theirs. Mostly, they need to see that you made it and they can too.
8. We either pay now or we pay later. There is a direct correlation between dropout rates and incarceration rates. We pay on the front end and invest in their education, or we pay on the back end with our taxes paying to house them as inmates. Which one seems like the better option for all of society?
What else can we do to improve our education system, ensuring our children don’t get left behind?
*Hope this does not read as if I am I’m an expert now on our education system because I’ve served as a substitute teacher. These are just my reflections. I’ve always had a strong interest in America’s education system.
Redefining Roles with an Ex
Some nights when I can’t sleep I lie in bed scrolling down my timeline on Twitter from my cell to see what folks are talking about. One night in particular I was shocked to see a gem of valuable wisdom that struck a cord in me so deep that I’ve thought on it for a few days now:
Ppl will create roles for u based upon their own insecurity. Just bc they r miserable they want u to be miserable. They are the ppl who are always like “you remember when u did xyz” even tho it was 10 years ago. Know that the person wants u in same role.
My god if the last of that statement didn’t describe my best friend, Wisdom. (I use ‘best friend’ loosely as our friendship is currently in a strange place.)
Of our nearly 10-year friendship the last two years have been unpredictably rocky. 2007-2008 we were in the intimate relationship/just friends/not speaking/a little more than friends but not monogamous/not speaking again phase. When I moved to grad school in January of 2009 I had decided I was done with him on all levels. On the last New Year’s we’d live in the same state he chose to get drunk and go to the club with his cousin. Meanwhile I went to church, came home, sat fully clothed with a flawlessly made up face watching TV while waiting on him to take me out. I finally fell asleep when he never showed. Well, he showed up at 6:00 a.m. I let him in. Long after he was knocked out I stared at the ceiling, eventually getting up to write. I knew that was the end. Once I moved we only spoke once in May. After that we didn’t speak again until January 2010. When I’m done, I’m truly done.
Since we restored our friendship last January we’ve been on pretty solid ground as friends. We didn’t see each other much because I was in school 460 miles away, but we talked occasionally, and when I went home it was on and poppin’ (not like that). Even though we were back in that platonic boat we always managed to steer toward the line of blur. The feelings were there, but he never wanted to commit. I could never figure out why until I realized, “He’s just not that into you,” although his actions and words said otherwise. But it was something about the title that he couldn’t get down with. So I got down with moving on.
In July when I started dating LI things changed, suddenly. He had a baby on the way and I was in a new relationship. I didn’t predict this leading to a change in our our friendship, but it happened.
I used to ask my girl friends, “Why he is acting funny? He never lets me talk about my new beau. He acts like LI doesn’t exist.”
“Cause he knows you got a good one this time,” they would say.
“Uhh uh. When I was with CB he didn’t act like this,” I’d retort.
“He knew that n**** wasn’t s*** and he was temporary,” they’d say. “Stop playing dumb.”
Maybe he did think I was the one that got away, but I wasn’t cocky enough to assume that’s what he thought that. But I don’t get why that would affect everything. The friendship I’d once known had vanished. We went from his house being my crashing spot when I visited home to not seeing each other at all on those visits.
When I read the tweet the other night I reflected over and over again on: They are the ppl who are always like “you remember when u did xyz” even tho [sic] it was 10 years ago. Know that the person wants u in the same role.
Every time Wisdom and I spoke on the phone for more than 30 minutes the conversation resulted in reminiscing. And I can honestly say he is the one who always initiated it. But when he’d retell stories of our “heyday,” it would quickly turn into, “You remember when you did [insert anything negative that happened in the course of our friendship or relationship]. Every.Single.Time. It was as if he was refusing to accept that I’ve evolved as a person, as a woman, by always reminding me of my shortcomings. If I would mention as much to him about doing this he’d always respond with some equivalent of relax and not to take everything so seriously.
He would take it a step further and ask, “Do you do [insert something I used to do with him when I loved dysfunctionally] to LI?”
I’d remain silent as he’d crack up, but he still anticipated an answer to his idiotic question. Referencing the tweet I thought to myself, ‘well if he wants me in the same role, as the tweet implies, what role is that?’ Is it the role of old best friend Benè who was young and out of control? More than friends Benè that was in love with a man who wouldn’t commit to her? Girlfriend Benè? Loving dysfunctionally Benè? What role is he trying to keep me in? Maybe it was all of the above, but if that’s the case, why? He criticized the flaws I had in those roles to no end, and still does.
I don’t think I’ll ever really know why. Perhaps as the tweet indicated, he’s miserable and wants to remind me of my mess-ups to make himself feel better. Maybe the role he’s constructed for me that needs redefining is based on his own insecurities. Although I never considered Wisdom to be a miserable person and still don’t (he always tries to find the good in everything), he is pretty discontent with his life. I believe he also held a deep insecurity about what I went on to achieve and where he was in his life even though I never looked at that way.* And because of that insecurity and others, he won’t allow himself to see I’m not who I was at 22 and 23. But he can’t see past that because that vision of me fits the construct he needs it to.
Whatever it is I need him to figure it out. Ahora! Because I just want my friend back, sans the remember what you did rhetoric. If that’s even possible.
*My friends back home swear because I have two degrees I’m successful. They think because they can Google me & shit comes up (a friend seriously did this) that I’ve somehow plateaued to some extraordinary level of success. This line of thinking has already ended one friendship. If only they knew my struggle in NY. I never looked at Wisdom through the lens of ‘he hasn’t done XYZ and I have accomplished WXYZ’. There’s nothing about my life that exudes success right now. So I just don’t look at things like that.
Rihanna vs. Lady Gaga
(Written for Jezebel February 9, 2011)
Rihanna is pushing the envelope with her latest salacious “S&M” video, which has resulted in it being allegedly banned by 11 countries according to the U.K.’s Daily Mirror. I guess chains and whips aren’t so exciting after all.
The banning of the video reeks of slut-shaming. Societies across the globe are incredibly uncomfortable with a woman overtly expressing her sexuality. A woman expressing her sexual desires outside of the realms of pleasing a man is seen as taboo. And when a woman breaks the confinements of patriarchy as it relates to sex, even if only artistically, she is taught her behavior is unacceptable.
But not all artists that are women are given a hard time for expressing themselves through their art.
While watching “S&M” repeatedly, I pondered about the whirlwind of controversy surrounding Rihanna’s video juxtaposed with Lady Gaga’s cinematic mini-films that are revered as art. Gaga’s over-the-top image and music is glorified as extraordinarily and arguably innovative (Madonna anyone?). But RiRi is just too hot too handle.
Remember Gaga’s “Alejandro” video? It simulates sex much more provocatively than “S&M.” Gaga in her latex nun get-up, the swallowing of rosaries, dry humping men in heels on the bed with their arms tied to the rail, was not exactly G-rated. And although the video raised some brows it was deemed art. “Paparazzi,” “Bad Romance” and “Telephone” all had their share of sexuality. There is an overwhelming sentiment that Gaga’s artistry was epic. Gaga has a catalog of overtly sexual videos prancing around in thongs and bra tops; and under the guise of art, Gaga warrants a certain level of acceptance Rihanna does not.
Rihanna’s good girl gone bad image is constantly questioned. Accusations of Rihanna being a slut are ever present. Society as a whole is uncomfortable with this 22-year old woman being so damn audacious. Gaga on the other hand remains unscathed. Gaga’s sexually expressive antics rock as long as it’s understood that her work is art. But what’s the difference between the two pop stars? Why is one revered while the other is too much to wrap our heads around?
Perhaps Rihanna’s “S&M” is not regarded as art because when people question if she has any actual talent. There is no denying that Rihanna is a star. One could even subjectively argue she makes good-catchy- music. But she is constantly criticized for her lackluster vocals. Contrarily Gaga’s talent is recognizable- pianist, songwriter and singer. You wouldn’t have much convincing to do to sell someone on the idea that Lady Gaga is a vocalist.
Eccentricity is another factor in Gaga’s art vs. Rihanna just being too damn much. Gaga exudes eccentric, free spirited, creative one. The eccentric artist types are not uncommon amongst white entertainers. No big deal. If one is indeed eccentric it is expected the music will follow suit of one’s image. Few people will consider Rihanna odd or even quirky. Rebel? Yes. Badass? Possibly. Eccentric? Nah. So even though “S&M” was a blatantly obvious metaphor symbolic of her relationship with the media, it is too out of the box for the images usually associated with a 22-year old Black pop singer. Rihanna’s work can’t possibly be art if people don’t really consider her an artist.
I wouldn’t discredit how much beauty may be tied into this as well. By most standards Rihanna is considered an attractive woman. Maybe the public subconsciously expects her to behave more prim and proper because of her looks. Lady Gaga is definitely not an ugly woman. But her attractiveness is often hidden by the theatrics of her image. Her theatrics scream gimmick. And with a gimmick you expect a certain shebang to go along with the act. Lady Gaga is seen as some super-human artist, which grants her the flexibility to be outlandishly bizarre because it falls under the umbrella of art. Rihanna on the other hand lacks the super-human quality. She is young pop singer we’ve literally watched transform from a soft-spoken sweet girl from the Barbados to a diva who makes no apologizes for being herself.
Badass Rihanna can be admired for her I don’t give a **** attitude when it comes to her sexuality, as long as she stays inside the box of who we think she is. But despite the conceptual creativity and aesthetic of the video; sadomasochism and a young pop singer who may not be seen as a true artist, is not afforded the privilege of her work being classified as art. Of course everything Gaga does is art (even if Madonna and Michael Jackson have already done it), because, well…she’s an artist. A “genius” one at that.
The Faces of Domestic Violence (Part II)
According to the National Coalition Against Domestic Violence, one in every four women will experience domestic violence in her lifetime. Eighty-five percent of domestic violence victims are women. And women ages 20-24 are at the greatest risk of suffering from nonfatal intimate partner violence (IPV). Sadly, like rape, most domestic violence cases are never reported to the police.
The Institute of Domestic Violence in the African-American Community reports that black women experience IPV at rates 35 percent higher than their white counterparts. In 2005 black women accounted for nearly 1/3 of the IPV homicides in America. These alarming statistics should be cause enough for women, men, teens, black, white and Latino to take domestic violence seriously, realizing it affects us all.
Yesterday I recounted my domestic violence experience that occurred nearly six years ago. I never wanted to write about it publicly for various reasons, but was compelled to do so with all of the articles, blogs and interviews focusing on the Chris Brown and Rihanna situation once again. Two years later I’ve found that opinions of what happened the night of the Grammy’s in 2009 haven’t evolved. There are those who believe Rihanna did something to deserve to be beaten, the people who wish everyone would just move on, the Rihanna supporters, Chris Brown stans and then there are people like me who cringe and refuse to be a fan of Brown because of how he abused Rihanna and his lack of remorse since.
Full disclosure: As a journalist I am NOT objective when it comes to issues of rape, violence against women, pedophilia, homophobia, sexism, misogyny, racism, injustice or inhumanity.
In monitoring the comments and attitudes about the domestic violence situation involving two huge pop stars, I’ve noticed how as a society and as a community, we are too tolerant of violence against women.
Chris Brown’s recent outburst at “Good Morning America” after Robin Roberts asked him about the attack against Rihanna has brought attention back to the horrific events. With Rihanna agreeing to Brown’s request to lift the restraining order, and Brown throwing temper tantrums, the pop stars are getting the exact opposite of what they would like- for everyone to just move on. In the April issue of Rolling Stone, Rihanna told Josh Ells:
We don’t have to talk again ever in my life. I just didn’t want to make it more difficult for him professionally. What he did to me was personal thing- it had noting to do with his career.
But it seems impossible for the public to drop it as if it never happened when violence against women is overlooked, results in victim blaming or glorified (see: Charlie Sheen).
Last June I wrote “Redemption, Resurrection & Bull” after Brown’s Oscar worthy cry me a river performance on BET. Although I showed Chris no mercy, I was more so angry at the prevailing attitude of women and men, mostly women, who argued we should forgive Brown. But forgiveness and accountability aren’t synonymous. And as much as Rihanna and Chris Brown have become the poster children of domestic violence in the black community, this isn’t so much about them as it is about us.
The prevalence of victim blaming is unnerving considering the astounding statistics of women, particularly women of color, experiencing intimate partner violence. It seems as if we are wired to automatically assume a women being abused deserved it. She must have hit him is too often an immediate reaction. And even if she did, are we so numb to violence that we think it’s ok for a man to retaliate by hitting her back? In the case of Brown and Rihanna, he didn’t hit her once, which is still never acceptable. He beat her senselessly.
My concern is that with the growing acceptance of violence against women, more and more women will suffer in silence. Our culture is contributing to women’s fear of telling their story, as it may result in being blamed, ignored or shamed for something they had no control over.
In the recent gang rape of an 11-year-old girl by 18 men in Cleveland, TX, the community’s response was to immediately protect the 18 black men who had all participated in raping an 11-year old girl. The community expressed very little outrage surrounding the fact that men ranging from ages 14- 27 participated, video taped and bragged about gang raping a child. I think about her situation, other sexual assault against women cases, and domestic violence and wonder, where is the safe haven for girls and women? It’s becoming more apparent that there isn’t one. And there should be.
Living as women in a patriarchal society that devalues women, especially black women, it is up to the entire village to educate, guide, mentor, love and listen to our young girls. Early on we must show them through our actions that emotional and physical abuse is not protocol. And it’s never love. Our young boys and men are in desperate need of guidance. Too many of them are roaming through life without the slightest idea of who they are, how to behave as men, what a man even looks like or what to do with all the pain they are carrying.
Domestic violence against women is a very real issue affecting too many people. Sweeping it under the rug or blaming women is a huge mistake. We must find a way to combat this ill, provide healing for the lives affected, and create a future generation that won’t be susceptible to violence against women. Domestic violence will implode if we don’t address begin addressing it now.
The Faces of Domestic Violence (Part I)
2005
I had no idea how seven policemen with their guns drawn ended up in the bedroom of my quaint 745 square foot apartment. But something tells me I should have been overjoyed since they potentially saved my life. When they entered my room they found my 5”10 180 lb boyfriend hovering over me as I laid there helpless. His strong grip had me pinned to the bed so that I couldn’t move. After what seemed like an eternity of him bashing my face in with his fist, slapping me, choking me and holding me hostage in my own apartment, it abruptly ended with the presence of the officers.
This would be the only time in my then 20 (now 26) years of living that I’d be happy to see the police.
I was 20 going into my senior year of college. I was younger than my peers because I graduated high school in three years. Living on campus for 2 ½ years was some of the best times of my life. When I moved home for a semester I couldn’t escape the arguments between my mother and I. I knew it was time to leave her house by any means necessary. Living on campus again wasn’t an option I was interested in. So I hustled the entire summer of 2005. I was working as a waitress at a country club in west Nashville. Waiting on wealthy white families wasn’t an ideal job, but the money was good for a 20-year old college student. I worked, stacked my money and searched for apartments. I kept telling my mother I was leaving, but she didn’t believe I’d actually be able to do it on my own. But just like her, once I’m determined to do something, you can consider it done. I finally found an apartment literally down the street from my aunt, her husband, two kids and my grandmother. This was perfect because I knew if I ever needed a home cooked meal or if something went wrong with my car, family was only minutes away. In retrospect, being in such close proximity to them was a blessing in disguise. My spacious one-bedroom apartment was under $500 for rent with water included. It had large closets, a huge bedroom, living room, dining room, a cute bathroom, dishwasher and central air, which is a given in most apartments back home. Damn you, NYC. Besides rent I only had to pay electricity and cable. I was officially an adult. I had a job, a car, was pursuing my bachelor’s degree and now held the keys to my own place. Oh, and I was in love with someone who was once my best friend.
2002
I met Martel on the very first day of college. It was always smoldering hot down south in August. All of the incoming freshmen were sent to an auditorium in the Humanities building to complete their registration. Waiting in a long line for at least an hour on the first day of college you eventually end up sparking a conversation with the people around you. Martel was witty, sarcastic and somewhat arrogant. He was from Detroit, and such a typical Detroit dude. I’m generalizing, but with good reason. He had a certain swagger about him that was enticing. He was more confident than he should have been based on his looks. But later in life his personality allowed me to overlook some of his flawed physical features. After leaving the Humanities building we walked while chatting as I headed back to my dorm in Wilson Hall, aka “The Zoo.” (I never called it that. Always hated that nickname). It was obvious he was feeling the kid. I kind of dug him too. After hesitation he asked for my number. I gave him the room number instead of my cell and told him I had a boyfriend so we could only be friends. I knew from day one being friends wasn’t what he had in mind. But that was our only option at the time.
For months we were strictly platonic, but shared many late night phone calls and deep conversations outside of my dorm. Martel and I learned a great deal about one another during that time. Jay-Z’s “Hard Knock Life” banger sounded like Kanye’s “Good Life” in comparison to Tel’s upbringing. He’d come from a single parent household where his mother was poor trying to raise five children on her own. She was a religious fanatic and severely strict. Martel eventually went to live with his father to escape the daily morning Bible readings and lack of freedom. He desperately longed for the day he could go outside to play with other kids instead of having to read Bible scriptures or clean the house from ceiling to floor. Living with his father wasn’t a vast improvement as far as living situations go. His father was a woman abuser, drug addict and also had very little money. I remember him vividly describing the days he would boil water to take a warm bath because there was no running hot water in the house. Saying he grew up rough is an understatement. I was always attracted to those types. Even though his unresolved issues from his past should have been a red flag for future behaviors, I felt the rough around the edges guys would be the only ones who understood me. Although I had never lived in the hood a day in my life, had never wanted for anything, had traveled overseas a slew of times by the 8th grade, watched my mom attain her Master’s degree while I was a child, I had other worldly experiences that I felt connected me to ‘hood dudes.
But I still had a boyfriend. Martel remained a very close friend. One my boyfriend hated. Eventually my first love and I parted ways for reasons that had absolutely nothing to do with Martel. And months later Martel and I were in couple’s bliss. Until we weren’t. After a few arguments we decided to remain friends. We were the friends who always still had a thing for one another, but no matter what we held on tight to our friendship. We’d lose touch, reconnect, lose touch and reconnect again in a matter of two and a half years.
2005
The summer before my senior year I was single as ever. Somehow Martel and I started hanging out again. He had recently moved into an apartment with his friend, and we were all living that HBCU college life. He didn’t go home to the D for the summer for obvious reasons. One night Martel expressed his feelings and said he didn’t want to just be my friend anymore. He straight up said being my man was the only option for him. I knew him better than he knew himself. He was very good to me at the time. He worshipped the ground I walked on. The one thing no one ever questioned was how much he loved me. We made it official, again, after two years of just friendship. But this time we weren’t 17 and 18 year old kids. We were 20 and 21 year old adults.
Our summer days were filled with work, chilling with friends, going out to eat, entertaining gusts at his house and whooping folks’ asses in Spades. Everything was very basic. We were young, struggling college students. There were no mommy and daddy credit cards for us. His apartment was the chill spot where folks would gather to play cards, bump music, laugh and drink. Things were good between Martel and I because we loved one another. Hard. Perhaps too hard. Later on I’d realize it was that type of dysfunctional love where arguments would resort to a “bitch” or “ho” rolling off either one of our tongues. We’d breakup to make up. And do it all again.
As summer was coming to an end Martel got into a fight with his roommate. Since his name wasn’t on the lease and he beat the dude up, his roommate kicked him out. At the time I was in the process of signing my first lease and buying furniture. I was overjoyed about getting my first place all on my own. I felt obligated as his girlfriend to offer my place to stay until he could figure things out. He took me up on that offer.
Moving into my place changed him. And it changed the dynamics of our relationship. Fast. It is one of the reasons I said I’d never live with someone again unless he was my fiancée. I saw a different side of him. He had fallen on hard times and couldn’t seem to catch a break. Eventually he found a job at a Dell plant about 45 minutes from my apartment. The battery to his blue Ford Explorer died, which left only me to take and pick him up from work. Summer was over and I was back in school and working now at J. Alexander’s as a waitress. Every day I would wake up at 4:30 a.m. to take him to work, get back home around 6:15 a.m., sleep for a few hours, get ready for class, go to school and be at work by the 4:00 p.m. dinner shift. I usually didn’t get off until at least 10:00 p.m. depending on how slow the restaurant was. I’d wake up and do it all again the next day.
On top of growing tired of feeling unappreciated, he was contributing very little to the household. He would pay bills, but financially I took care of 95% of everything. This caused a majority of our arguments. I’d put him out, let him come back, he’d leave voluntarily and I’d let him come back. I was young and in love with a man.
The arguments started to escalate. There were several instances that screamed ‘caution, this dude could snap.’ But I never thought he’d actually hit me. It was painstakingly obvious we didn’t need to be together, only neither of us could let go. We were extremely similar to Ronnie and Sammie from “Jersey Shore.” But worse. I always rationalized his temper by taking part of the blame. I was not an easy person to deal with either. And there were many days that I provoked him. At least that’s what I told myself. Plus, I’d convinced myself this is what real love was. Willingly, I was ride or die.
One day I was straightening up the apartment before I left for work when I saw an empty cigarette box on the counter. I was annoyed. Like, just put the box in the trash. Not only was I in school full-time, working full-time, paying the bulk of the bills, I was semi-cooking and definitely cleaning with very little help. I started thinking to myself, ‘What the hell does this Negro do?’ I had switched from smoking Newports to Kools months before so I knew it wasn’t my empty cigarette box so I mentioned as much to him.
“Man, how hard is it to just throw away an empty cigarette box? Why would you leave it on the counter?” I asked.
“F*ck you. Shut the f*ck up. Always b*tching about something,” he yelled.
His screaming only got louder by the minute. I couldn’t possibly understand why he was so mad over a cigarette box. After going back and forth with him for two minutes I decided to get ready for work. I couldn’t get dressed fast enough to get away from him even if it was only for a few hours.
“You might as well call off today. You ain’t going to work,” he said. “Your ass is gon’ stay right here with me,” he demanded.
“You’re crazy as hell if you think I’m not about to go to work to make this money,” I replied.
Out of nowhere he grabbed and slammed me onto my bed. His eyes were unrecognizable. When he looked at me he no longer saw his girlfriend, the woman who kept him from being homeless on the streets, his best friend or his lover. I imagine he saw just a bitch he hated. The same bitch he blamed for all the pain in his life. And that day was going to be the day I paid for every wrong ever done to him.
When he slammed me on the bed my natural instinct was to raise myself up as quickly as possible. After hitting me in my face with his fist I went bananas- kicking and punching him all at the same time. That’s when he figured out he would have to restrain me because I wasn’t going to lie there and not fight back. He held me by my wrists leaving me helpless, unable to move. I felt paralyzed. To this day I will spazz out if my wrists are held in any way that could prevent me from moving or escaping.
Every time I’d retaliate he’d hit me with a harder blow. The blows were coming so fast there was nothing I could do but watch the man I had loved with every breath in my body wail on me as if I was his worst enemy. At one point I wondered, Is this how I’m going to die? When he took a break from hitting me he choked me out while spewing hateful words. How could this be Martel doing this to me? I wished I had been dreaming. I went into survival mode after realizing fighting back only led to more pounds. There was a point where he halted from beating me and would just stare at me telling me I made him do this, I brought this on myself. I guess his plan was to hold me hostage and torture me all day. Whatever his plan was I desperately needed to not be a part of it. I screamed. He’d shut me up. I screamed again. He’d shut me up.
Luckily my screams were not in vain. Out of nowhere police women and men galore were in my bedroom with guns drawn yelling for him to release me. The physical blows were finally over. But the mental scars would remain for many years to come.
It was two days before Christmas. Our artificial beautifully decorated tree had a ton of presents under it. What once seemed like a representation of our first Christmas together now looked like an oversized plant that had died from the lack of oxygen and water. In that moment the only thing that was apparent was what we now were: an abuser and a domestic violence victim. [1]
He was handcuffed and searched in the living room by the police officers. Without a doubt he was going to jail. Even after what he did to me, it was painful seeing a black man now becoming a part of the criminal justice system I despised. While searching him for weapons I presume, the cops found an ounce of weed on him that he’d purchased to try to bring in some extra money. In addition to the domestic violence charge the state slapped another charge on him for possession of marijuana. An EMT ambulance waited outside to take me to the hospital because the knot on the side of my head was as thick as a golf ball. The medics warned me the knot could be a concussion, but I didn’t care. I didn’t want to go the hospital. It was embarrassing. I was humiliated. How could something like this happen to me? I wasn’t this girl.
After being coerced to ride to the hospital in an ambulance, alone, where I looked so broken down that once at the hospital complete strangers warned me, If you go back to him he will kill you my grandmother picked me up from the hospital. She didn’t understand how someone so put together could let a man hit me. As I slowly walked to my apartment door wanting only to die, or at the very least slip under the covers for eternity, I saw a white envelope taped to my door. I felt empty inside. A part of my soul was missing. I opened the envelope to find a letter from the apartment complex management. Basically because of his possession of marijuana and not being a tenant on the lease, I had 72 hours to vacate the apartment. Merry Christmas.
I was so numb I couldn’t cry. I called my aunt and her husband to tell them the news. My aunt immediately offered her house as a temporary home for as long as I needed. My mother never offered. I’m still working on forgiving her for that. We made arrangements to start loading the truck the next day. The sooner I got out of there, the better. I finally crawled in my bed. Alone. I cried for hours. Hours turned into days. Because I had to move out of my apartment within three days, I didn’t have the time to stay in the bed sobbing. So I’d cry every chance I could while in solitude. My spirit was broken while his was incarcerated. I’ve never quite looked at men the same. And so it’s clear, just like most domestic violence victims, just like Rihanna, I went back.
* Part II will NOT recount this story any further. It will explore domestic violence in the black community, why we rally in support of protecting black men, victim blaming and why we should all care about the infamous beating of Rihanna by Chris Brown.
[1] I never referred to myself as a victim of domestic violence. It actually took me five years to even write about this incident because of how ashamed and stupid I felt. I also never wanted people to feel sorry for me. Or worse, say I deserved it.
The Ins and Outs of Journalism
Journalism is all about paying your dues. Degree(s) are not enough. Clips alone won’t seal the deal either. It takes persistence, tough skin, accepting that you will hear the word ‘no’ frequently, sleeping about 5 hours a night, being in the know about everything from politics to the latest celeb to adopt another African baby and knowing there are 1,000 people in line ready to take your spot. You must have a passion for what you do.
I know my life wouldn’t be complete without writing. But I’m starting to question if my passion is really in journalism.
Not moving to NYC was not an option. I will rob Peter to pay Paul to be here because it is truly the hub of the media industry. I’m far from attaining my goals, but they are at least in my peripheral with me here. But do I really care about chasing a story? Reporting hard news doesn’t exactly tickle my fancy. My dream job, I can’t believe I’m writing this publicly, is to work as a columnist, which is under the journalism umbrella. Thing is, you don’t just skip to columnist status without doing extensive reporting throughout your career. With the end goal being to eventually publish a number of books, I often wonder if I should just get to writing a book and screw all the hobnobbing of trying to join the inner circle of journalists.
In today’s world of blogging, citizen journalism and the burgeoning of online magazines/newspapers (even if the websites traditionally wouldn’t be considered credible journalism), it is apparent people don’t really know the difference. Everybody with a laptop and WordPress account considers themselves a writer. An opinion + a blog does not a writer make. And people don’t get that a blogger isn’t necessarily a writer or journalist. I’ve laughed countless times at readers online that have called me a “journalist” as if I am a poseur. It slightly annoys me knowing I’ve gone to school for a certain skill, have executed this skill through actual reporting clips, then someone basically attempts to discredit what I do. At the same time I brush it off because I understand the lines are so blurred.
Then there is the big O. Objectivity is such a crucial component to journalism. Once you’ve singed up for the rocky road of a life as a journalist, you’re under a microscope for anything that may violate the ethics of journalism. Censorship becomes one with your daily conscious. Should I tweet this? Can I say that?
Commentary pieces are not exactly objective and tend to be completely subjective with facts thrown in here and there. We all know I’ve been all commentary everything for the past year. At least 75% of my clips are Op-Ed. Not only do commentary clips amount to the equivalent of an unsigned check, commentary can get you in trouble. A fellow journalist told me last week, “You know you should be careful with your Steve Harvey piece. He is cool with a lot of the top people at big publications. And what if you have to interview him one day?” *turns up Jay Z’s “Can I Live?”*
Writing for Free
Not something I’m willing to do unless the NYT called me up tomorrow. Not only would I write for free for the NYT, I’d do it under the most dire circumstances. Other than that writers should be compensated. Again, you have to pay your dues in this industry with blood, sweat and tears. But you also have to know when to start setting a standard for yourself. Print journalism is one of the only fields people expect you to provide a service for free. A broadcast journalist wouldn’t be expected to come in and assist the Producer of the news program for free would they? It’s not that I’m above writing for free because I’ve done it. I interned at VIBE magazine for free. In fact, I had to pay my University to get credit for that internship AND pay to rent a room in Jamaica, Queens. But that’s how bad I wanted it. I’ve written countless online articles for free to build my portfolio and gain exposure. I never once complained because you got to do what you got to do. At some point though a publication has to respect the time you’re putting into writing articles. I was told any reputable publication will pay its writers. Ha! Tell that to Huffington Post.
Honestly, the rejection takes a toll on your self-esteem. You can be the best writer or journalist in the game, which I would never claim to be, but it will not make you immune to getting pitches rejected, writing a wonderfully written piece only for it not to be ran by the publication at the last minute, not getting emails returned from editors, having to persistently pursue editors at pubs you want to write for without being annoying, having folks not know who you are so they won’t want to take a chance on you, seeing people get opportunities in your field who aren’t technically journalists. It all happens. But I promise you will see the fruits of your labor if you are built to take the blows, get back up and keep at it.
Journalism is one of the hardest industries to break into, but of course I say that without ever having really attempted to succeed in any other field. When I interviewed CNN anchor Suzanne Malveaux she said this much without even being prompted. You know it’s hard. Now the question is, is it worth it to you? I’m still trying to figure that out. Writing definitely is. I just don’t know if journalism is where my heart is. And if that’s the case I’m in a shitload of trouble.
Changing the Face of Politics
It is not uncommon for the mister and I to discuss a range of topics while eating dinner. We laugh, get passionate, and agree to disagree on everything from the latest news to celebrities to thought provoking articles we’ve read. Usually the conversation shifts to the state of our community because this is one of the things we are both extremely passionate about. You probably think of me as some ‘fro rocking, fist in the air, black power, Angela Davis type, always talking about “the people.” I do indeed rock an ‘fro, but I promise I’m not sitting around griping about “the man.” I just love my people.
Yesterday, the beau and I had dinner with his father in which our discussion primarily focused on politics and its relationship to people of color. After watching the State of the Union address, watching news commentators analyze President Obama’s speech and reading a few of the next day headlines, I was curious as to what others thought about the address.
My thoughts on the SOTU aren’t really that important. However, I thought radio host, journalist, hip-hop historian, activist and deejay Davey D’s post “Thoughts on State of the Union: Great Speech, Great ACT-Key Word ‘Act’” summed up what many Americans are feeling, but may deem too unpatriotic to express. The post is definitely worth the read. A few lines from Davey D’s post:
It was clear last night with all the flowery rhetoric, President Obama was concerned about one thing… getting himself into political position to be re-elected. That’s his agenda. That’s his interest. As former Vice presidential candidate Rosa Clemente pointed out in our round table interview the other day, ‘President Obama’s job was to make a good speech to make everyone feel better even as things are progressively getting worse for many’.
His job is to prop us up. keep the proverbial natives from being restless and run some more game that takes us further down the hole. That’s his goal. What’s ours?…
He continues:
We did this in 2000 when millions of voters were disenfranchised in Florida as we watched all 100 senators including the fool we voted for Al Gore, not raise their hands to fight for further investigations and recount counts. Y’all remember that right? Y’all remember the opening scene in Michael Moore’s documentary Fahrenheit 9-11?
So last night’s State of the Union was hollow and the realization that as much as I would like and naively expected, this president is not trying to address the realities that are impacting my world on a daily. There is obviously another audience he feels needs to be reached. Maybe its corporate backers, or some phantom independent voters in the middle of the country. Whatever the case it’s certainly not the activists who was leading those huge marchers or organizing to bring about the changes I described.
So God Bless to those he was speaking to. For the rest of us, we understand this script. We dust ourselves off, regroup and come up with a better game plan…one that ensures the interests of poor and working class are not only protected but pushed forward. That’s the goal for 2012 Support and votes are not guaranteed
That’s how President Obama is playing it. He doesn’t see us as friends, his homies or anything like that. He sees us as potential voters who need to be seduced or conquered into buying his agenda, which bears little reflection of our realities. I understand.
Great Speech, Great show. President Obama deserves an Oscar. His act is convincing. key word ‘Act’.
Interesting.
Back to last night’s dinner. The three of us pondered how collectivity the state of black people has gotten worse since the Civil Rights movement and yes, integration. My argument was heavily based in the idea that if the Tea Party, which only grew after the election of President Obama, could organize, receive sickening amounts of media coverage, influence policy makers and have their demands heard, it is the very least people of color could do.
Davey D reminds us that we’ve been in the trenches organizing for a long time. And we have. But it isn’t enough. Our needs aren’t being met, we are still oppressed and injustices still happen to us far too often. How long are we going to wait for someone else to fix our problems? How long are we going to discuss the reason our communities are the way they are without actions complementing the discourse?
The beau made a great point. “New York, the Mecca of hip-hop, couldn’t even get Kevin Powell elected.” Perhaps this is an indication of black people and the youth’s relationship with politics. And maybe we have to become more politically involved to further our causes.
Is politics imperative in the fight for the change? Do black people need a movement or revolution of some sort in order for things to change? Does Davey D’s sentiments of the SOTU resonate with you?
*I highly suggest reading Tim Wise’s “Imagine if the Tea Party was Black” article.
Steve Harvey and Black Women
It was in 2009 when the state of black women’s singleness became newsworthy, studied by experts and a topic that everyone from bloggers to self-proclaimed relationship experts couldn’t stop writing about. Everyone from Nightline to the Washington Post weighed in on the “something must be wrong with black women” meme. Including black men.
Advising black women on how to get and keep a man is now seen as big business with comedian and radio host Steve Harvey leading the pack. He has turned what some would call black women’s dire circumstances (70% of children being born out of wedlock, 42% of black women never having married), into dollar signs.
For Harvey it all started with his radio show’s “Strawberry Letter” segment where women would write in asking for his advice on their relationships. Harvey would give no holds barred tough love answers similar to that of an uncle. It was almost inevitable Harvey would turn that opportunity into his first book, Act Like a Lady, Think Like a Man. Harvey’s first book went on to sell over 2 million copies spending 64 weeks on the New York Times bestseller list. In fact, Harvey’s first book was the second-biggest non-fiction book of 2009, behind only Sarah Palin’s Going Rogue.
His decision to write a second book Straight Talk, No Chaser after such success was as predictable as Tyler Perry making another Madea movie. And like Perry, his formulaic method is apparently what audiences want. Not even two months old, his second book is also a NYT Bestseller.
In my heart of hearts I want to believe that 2 million women did not purchase his first book. I want to believe that his second book is not really a NYT Bestseller and this is all a cruel joke. But it’s not. The reality is that there are black women out there who don’t understand when we are being pimped. Exploited. All for the sake of the almighty dollar.
Recently a video of Steve Harvey’s second ex-wife of 16 years hit the net. She accused him of cheating during their marriage, read letters from a mistress and even accused Harvey’s current wife of being the mistress while they were still married.
Why would we, in droves, listen to a comedian turned “relationship guru” who has been married three times? Help me to understand what would be appealing about taking his advice seriously.
At the core the problem is patriarchy. And that is no easy task to dismantle. Women are conditioned as hell.
Unfortunately, the media, black men and seems like the world is constantly telling black women we are undesirable and we are the problem. Statistics are used to validate this claim. In return, women in massive numbers believe that any black male celebrity who comes along to offer his golden advice, whether it is Hill Harper, Jimi Izrael or Steve Harvey, must have the master key of unlocking the gates to love. We have to stop this y’all.
Ask yourself why isn’t Steve making books for black men. Hell, they have a host of issues that need to be dealt with. Statistically they may be worse off than black women. But he knows better. Harvey knows that he wouldn’t sell more than 10,000 copies, let alone 2 million, targeting black men.
Knowing that women aren’t listening to other women writing books of the same genre is also very telling. Wouldn’t it make sense to read the perspective of a woman who most likely understands, empathizes and has been through some of the same joys and pains? Iyanla Vanzant has written books both dedicated to women and men in an effort so build stronger relationships in our community. Former NFL wife Shanae Hall wrote a counter to Harvey’s book Why Do I Have to Act Like a Man?. In 1999 author Denene Millner and husband Nick Chiles wrote What Brothers Think, What Sistahs Know about black relationships. What Steve Harvey is doing is nothing new.
It’s really unnerving that there are black men who choose to capitalize off of some of black women’s belief they need some type of help on finding or keeping a man. But it saddens me that we allow them to do it.
It is not my intention to make black women who do read Harvey’s books feel bad. Women have different reasons for reading what he writes and love is the one thing we all desire. However, every time women support one of these self-help books written by men who are not preaching the same garbage to their male counterparts, we are contributing to a patriarchal system capitalizing off of our desires. We are essentially telling men, ‘Keep dictating to us on who we should be and what we should do. We’ll keep supporting it.’ And that’s not something any of us should be willing to do.